Let’s talk ↗
Menu
Our expertiseM&ANXD Family OfficePartnersResource CentreAbout usContact
← Resource Centre
Leadership / Founder mentoring

What Would You Do?

The cost of making the wrong decision — and why even the world’s most successful CEOs don’t go it alone.

Who do you turn to when everyone else expects you to have the answers?

It’s a question I’ve been thinking about increasingly over recent years.

Throughout my business career, I’ve lost count of the number of founders and business owners who have asked me a relatively simple question.

“What would you do?”

Sometimes it’s about acquiring another business, raising investment, managing a difficult employee, reviewing the numbers or deciding whether to change direction.

Sometimes it’s more personal.

“Am I doing the right thing?”

“Should I keep going?”

“Have I lost sight of what I’m trying to achieve?”

And sometimes, they simply need somebody to listen.

I’ve spent more than 40 years in business, holding senior positions from Sales and Marketing Director to Managing Director, as well as founding, acquiring, growing and exiting businesses.

I’ve managed teams of fewer than ten people and organisations employing several hundred. I’ve worked internationally across banking, financial services, data, technology, legal and professional services, luxury products and other industries.

I’ve experienced exits at 14 times EBITDA and returns of 200 times my original investment. I’ve been involved in significant acquisitions, integrations, capital raises and business sales.

But some of the most valuable conversations I’ve had have been with founders whose businesses are worth a fraction of those larger transactions.

Because the challenges of leadership aren’t always proportionate to the size of the business.

What’s the cost of getting it wrong?

Business owners regularly question the cost of professional advice.

But how often do they calculate the cost of making a poor decision?

A senior appointment that doesn’t work out.

An acquisition that looked attractive but turns into a distraction.

A funding agreement that unnecessarily dilutes the founders.

A new market entered too early.

Or a business strategy that continues long after the evidence suggests it should change.

These decisions can cost tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands or considerably more.

And sometimes the most expensive decision is the one you never make.

The question isn’t whether an experienced adviser can guarantee the right answer. Nobody can.

It’s whether having someone independent to challenge your assumptions might help you avoid mistakes, recognise opportunities and make better-informed decisions.

The Americans have understood something important

In the United States, successful business leaders have increasingly embraced the idea of surrounding themselves with trusted advisers, mentors and executive coaches.

And the evidence is striking.

A 2025 study by Stanford Graduate School of Business, the Hoover Institution and The Miles Group found that 95% of the CEOs surveyed used professional coaches or informal advisers.

Some 58% used professional coaches, while 82% relied on trusted informal advisory networks.

On average, these CEOs consulted four informal advisers on work-related matters.

Think about that.

Some of the most experienced and successful business leaders actively seek independent perspectives on the decisions they make.

Not because they lack ability.

Because they recognise the value of challenging their own thinking.

Eric Schmidt, former CEO of Google, famously described the advice he received from board member John Doerr:

“Everybody needs a coach.”

Schmidt subsequently worked with Bill Campbell, who became a trusted adviser to some of Silicon Valley’s most influential business leaders.

Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates has made a similar point:

“Everyone needs a coach.”

The principle is straightforward. Even exceptionally talented people benefit from feedback, perspective and constructive challenge.

I believe this approach deserves to become a much more established part of British entrepreneurial culture.

We have excellent accountants, lawyers, bankers and corporate advisers.

But how many SME founders have somebody they can call when they simply need to talk through an important decision?

Someone who knows their business, understands their ambitions and isn’t trying to sell them something.

Being a founder can be incredibly lonely

There’s a particular kind of pressure that comes with owning and running a business.

Your employees expect leadership.

Your investors expect results.

Your customers expect delivery.

Your family expects you to know what you’re doing.

But who do you speak to when you’re uncertain?

Your management team may have different priorities. Your investors have financial interests. Your professional advisers understandably look at issues through their own specialisms.

Sometimes what you really need is someone independent.

Someone who has experienced similar challenges.

Someone prepared to tell you what they genuinely think, even when it isn’t what you want to hear.

Over the years, founders have frequently told me how much better they felt after we’d talked through a difficult situation.

Not because I necessarily provided the answer.

Often, they already knew what needed to happen.

They simply needed the confidence, perspective and reassurance to move forward.

And sometimes they needed someone to challenge them and say, “Have you considered doing something completely different?”

It’s not just about the difficult times

Interestingly, I think independent mentoring can be just as valuable when a business is doing well.

Success brings its own challenges.

Revenue is increasing. The business is growing. New opportunities are appearing.

But are you concentrating on the right things?

Should you expand internationally?

Acquire a competitor?

Bring in external investment?

Recruit a more experienced management team?

Or would the business be better served by improving margins, strengthening cash flow and concentrating on its existing customers?

Growth can be exciting, but it can also be distracting.

Sometimes a founder needs somebody who will ask the uncomfortable question:

“Why are you doing this?”

Or perhaps:

“Is this really the best use of your time and money?”

Accountability matters too.

It’s remarkably easy to become consumed by the day-to-day demands of running a business and lose sight of the objectives that mattered six months earlier.

Having someone who understands those objectives and periodically brings you back to them can be enormously valuable.

Forty years of lessons — including the difficult ones

One thing I’ve learnt over four decades is that experience isn’t simply about the successes.

It’s about the mistakes, the disappointments, the difficult negotiations, the opportunities you missed and the occasions when you wish you’d listened to somebody else’s advice.

I’ve experienced all of those.

I’ve been a founder, an executive, an acquirer, a seller, an investor and an adviser.

I’ve worked with small entrepreneurial businesses and much larger international organisations.

And I’ve learnt that while every business is different, many of the underlying challenges are remarkably familiar.

People. Cash. Customers. Strategy. Leadership. Timing. Judgement.

The details change, but the fundamental decisions often don’t.

Perhaps the greatest value of experience is recognising situations early enough to do something about them.

What if you had someone in your corner?

For some time, founders and business owners have said to me:

“I wish I could just pick up the phone to you when something comes up.”

Not to commission a consultancy report.

Not to arrange a formal board meeting.

Simply to have a confidential conversation with someone who has been there before.

Someone who can help them think through a difficult decision, challenge their strategy, review an opportunity or regain their focus.

It’s something I’ve been considering making available on a more structured basis.

A small, exclusive group of founders who would have direct personal access to me as a trusted, independent mentor and commercial sounding board.

Not unlimited consultancy. Not a substitute for their professional advisers or board.

A personal relationship built on experience, perspective, constructive challenge, accountability and mutual trust.

I’m considering opening just five places initially, with a maximum of ten, because I want to ensure that every relationship receives the attention it deserves.

The intention would be to work together over six or twelve months, allowing enough time to understand the business, build trust and make a meaningful contribution.

It won’t be right for everyone.

But for founders who value experience, are open to challenge and recognise that they don’t need to make every decision alone, I believe it could be worthwhile.

After all, if some of the world’s most successful business leaders recognise the value of trusted independent counsel, why shouldn’t the founders of Britain’s SMEs?

Let’s start a conversation

If you’re a founder or business owner, whether you’re just starting out, building momentum, scaling, transforming or considering an exit, I’d genuinely welcome hearing your perspective.

Perhaps you’re facing a decision that you’re struggling to make.

Perhaps things are going well, but you’re questioning what should come next.

Or perhaps you’d simply value having someone independent, experienced and commercially minded to speak to from time to time.

I’d be interested to hear from you.

I’m exploring the creation of a small, invitation-led group of founders with whom I can work personally, sharing some of the lessons, experiences and perspectives I’ve gained over the past 40 years.

There is no obligation and no formal application process at this stage. Just an opportunity to have a conversation and see whether there might be value in working together.

You can contact me directly through NXD Team or connect with me on LinkedIn.

Because sometimes, one conversation can change how you see a problem.

And sometimes, it can change what you decide to do next.

So, what would you do?

Chris McDonald is Founder and CEO of NXD Group, with more than 40 years’ experience in senior leadership, business ownership, acquisitions, investment, international transactions and corporate advisory.

Sources & further reading

  1. Stanford Graduate School of Business / Hoover Institution: 2025 CEO Coaching and Kitchen Cabinet Survey ↗Published 1 September 2025
  2. Stanford Graduate School of Business: 2013 Executive Coaching Survey ↗Published 31 July 2013
  3. Tim Ferriss / Eric Schmidt: Eric Schmidt interview: coaching and Bill Campbell ↗Published 11 April 2019

Start a conversation with Chris ↗

Explore the Resource Centre ↗
NEWS & INSIGHTS

Keep up to date with the Team.

To keep up to date with new developments and articles from the Team, please provide your details here.

You can unsubscribe at any time using our online unsubscribe form or by emailing chris.mcdonald@nxdteam.com.